Leading the Board: Mastering the Chair Role

Whether you're a Non-Executive Director contemplating your first Chair role or an Executive Director planning your portfolio career, the position of Chair is both incredibly fulfilling and prestigious, representing the pinnacle of corporate leadership. However, with this esteemed role comes significant responsibility. Inspired by my recent podcast episode with Sir Christopher Haworth, "Mastering the Role: How to Be an Effective Chair" I delve deeper into this topic to offer further insights and support for those aspiring to excel as a Chair. In this blog post, I will explore the essential qualities, skills, and strategies that define an effective Chair, providing practical advice and actionable steps to help you navigate the complexities of this critical role. Whether you're looking to enhance your leadership capabilities or seeking guidance on how to foster a productive and cohesive board, this comprehensive guide aims to equip you with the knowledge and confidence needed to succeed at the highest level.

Let’s get the basics clear, what is a board chair?

To be a board chair is to be the steward of the board's collective wisdom, guiding strategic decisions with integrity and fostering a culture of trust and collaboration. It's about leading with purpose and ensuring the organisation's vision is realised.

A good Chair is akin to a maestro, guiding, coaching, and challenging the board to ensure all members are aligned and working harmoniously. In essence, being an effective Chairperson involves helping directors become a highly effective and collaborative decision-making team that isn't afraid to challenge each other or management.

Effective Chairs recognise the importance of fostering a cooperative and respectful environment where all directors feel heard and valued. They ensure that discussions are productive and that decisions are made thoughtfully. Additionally, they must maintain clear communication with the CEO, offering guidance and support while also holding them accountable. An effective Chair is a leader, facilitator, and strategist, capable of steering the board and the organisation towards success.

The difference between the Chair and the CEO

Understanding the distinction between the Chair and the CEO is crucial. The Chair leads the board, not the organisation, acting as a facilitator of effective board discussions rather than a commander-in-chief. Many former CEOs who transition to the role of Chair often struggle with this difference. Moving from 'doing' to 'helping others to do' requires self-awareness and practice, but an effective Chair finds great satisfaction in seeing the board reach decisions with minimal direct input.

It's often said that if you enjoy the spotlight, being a Chair might not be the right role for you. Being an effective Chair is about creating conditions for others to shine, characterised by restraint, non-domineering behaviour, and allowing room for others. Effective Chairs focus on processes and people, while CEOs concentrate on executing tasks. Both roles are vital but fundamentally different.

A Chair is not a CEO. The Chair's role is to lead the board and facilitate effective governance, while the CEO's role is to manage the organisation's operations and execute the board's strategy. Both roles are crucial, but they serve different purposes and require different approaches.

Responsibilities of the Board Chair

The role of the board chair encompasses a variety of important responsibilities. Other board members look to the chair to guide them and set a positive, energised tone for meetings. Given the significance of these responsibilities, the current board chair often mentors another board member during their term to prepare a successor.

An effective board chair is proficient in the following areas:

Leadership: As the leader of the board, the chair is the main contact for other board members and must be available when needed. The chair takes attendance at board meetings and encourages active participation from all members.

Agendas: The chair collaborates with the executive director and the secretary to establish meeting agendas, which should include the meeting's purpose and discussion items. This structure helps the chair manage the meeting efficiently and ensures productivity.

Subscribe to the Truth about Local Government podcast

Meeting Management: The chair presides over board and executive committee meetings, calling special meetings as necessary. Using the agenda as a guide, the chair steers the board towards decision-making and ensures meetings conclude on time.

Committee Direction: In collaboration with the executive director, the chair recommends committee chairs for board approval and serves as an ex-officio member of all committees.

Relationship with the Executive Director: The chair's relationship with the executive director is built on mutual trust and respect. The executive director relies on the chair for assistance with emerging issues and potential problems, and they collaborate on board agenda topics.

Executive Director Performance Appraisal: The entire board is responsible for the annual performance appraisal of the executive director, with the chair taking the lead. The chair typically appoints a committee for this purpose and sets the timeline and parameters for the evaluation.

Board Conduct: By modelling, articulating, and upholding the rules of conduct as outlined in the bylaws, the chair sets a high standard for board behaviour. The chair also addresses issues related to confidentiality, conflict of interest, and other pertinent policies.

Board Learning and Development: The chair plays a key role in recruiting and developing new board members and seeks opportunities for continuing education to enhance the board's collective skill set.

Succession Planning: A newly appointed chair must identify and recruit a potential successor to ensure board continuity and a smooth transition. The chair mentors the chair-elect in their duties.

Keep the shareholders updated

As a Chair, it's crucial to engage with shareholders and keep them updated regularly through consistent and timely communications like newsletters, emails, or meetings. Transparency is key, sharing both successes and challenges to build trust. Providing feedback channels ensures shareholders feel heard and valued. Tailoring updates to specific interests makes information more relevant, while using visuals and interactive content enhances engagement. Promptly addressing questions or concerns fosters strong, collaborative relationships, ensuring shareholders remain engaged and informed.

Board Self-Evaluations: Annually, the chair coordinates a process for board self-evaluation and implements recommendations for improvement, including feedback on their performance.

Differentiating the Board Chair vs. Executive Director: While both roles have authority, their responsibilities differ significantly. The executive director manages day-to-day operations, while the chair leads the board, runs meetings, and oversees the organisation alongside the board. Both roles are crucial and require close collaboration to ensure alignment and fulfil the organisation's vision.

The role of a board chair is to inspire and guide, to listen and to lead. It's about creating an environment where every board member feels valued and motivated to contribute to the organisation's success.

Board Chair Tips for Conducting Effective Board Meetings

Preparation is the cornerstone of an effective board meeting. Many nonprofits use executive committee meetings where the board’s officers decide which items should be on the agenda and which can wait. The board chair can then develop a suitable agenda, finalise the board books, and ensure that board members are ready to actively participate in the meeting.

Here are some helpful tips for conducting board meetings:

• Use executive sessions as a steering committee to prioritise agenda topics.

• Set a realistic agenda that allows the board to address all items within the designated time limit.

• Utilise board management software to create board books, take minutes, share calendars, and more.

• Communicate with board members before the meeting to ensure they’re prepared.

• Send out notifications of follow-ups to ensure board members address them before the meeting.

• Set time limits for each agenda item and adhere to them.

• Engage all board members in discussions.

• Thank the board members for their time and adjourn on time.

A board chair is the guardian of the board's integrity, ensuring that every decision is made with the organisation's best interests at heart. It's about leading with wisdom and fostering a spirit of collaboration

Effective Chairs exhibit several key attributes:

• Authority and humility: Chairs must command respect from directors, executives, and key stakeholders to guide the board through challenging decisions. However, they also need to let others shine. Effective Chairs balance their authority with humility, focusing on processes and people.

• Commitment and detachment: A Chair's presence should be felt as little as possible, yet as much as necessary. The company's interests should always come first, balanced by maintaining sufficient distance. This allows the Chair to view the company with an outsider's perspective at times, leaving room for executives to manage operations.

• Incisiveness and patience: Chairs must be attentive to the ideas of other board members, as patience is crucial for effective decision-making. Good Chairs don't rush to complete tasks quickly but focus on doing them properly. They prioritise effectiveness over efficiency.

To be a board chair is to be the anchor in turbulent times, providing stability and direction while empowering the board to navigate challenges with confidence and unity.

In conclusion, the role of a Chair is both a prestigious and demanding position that requires a unique blend of leadership, strategic thinking, and interpersonal skills. As you consider stepping into this role, reflect on the key points discussed in this article: the importance of fostering a collaborative and respectful board environment, maintaining clear and transparent communication, and balancing authority with humility. Remember, an effective Chair not only guides the board through complex decisions but also empowers its members to contribute their best. By embracing these principles, you can lead with confidence and drive your organisation towards success. If you are ready to take on this challenge, the insights shared here will serve as a valuable foundation for your journey.

This blog post was sponsored by Local Partnerships LLP, who help local authorities to deliver projects and implement changes efficiently. They offer expertise in climate adaptation, energy efficiency, waste management, housing, infrastructure, procurement, and digital transformation, ensuring excellent value for money and meeting key priorities.