Turning Tension into Progress: Navigating Difficult Conversations in Local Government

In the dynamic world of local government, difficult conversations are not just part of the job—they are central to it. Whether you’re an officer leading a transformation programme or an elected member balancing political priorities with community expectations, you will inevitably face challenging discussions. These may involve colleagues, residents, partner organisations, or political counterparts. They may centre on budget cuts, service redesigns, or differing visions for the future. But here’s the truth: difficult conversations are not roadblocks—they are catalysts for progress.

Handled well, these conversations can unlock innovation, strengthen relationships, and drive meaningful change. Handled poorly, they can stall projects, damage trust, and entrench division. This article explores why these conversations matter, what makes them difficult, and—most importantly—how to navigate them with confidence, clarity, and purpose.

Subscribe to the Truth about Local Government podcast

Why Difficult Conversations Matter

Local government is undergoing profound and often rapid change. Reorganisation, financial constraints, digital transformation, and shifting public expectations are reshaping how councils operate. In this context, difficult conversations are not just about conflict—they are about passion, values, and the pursuit of better outcomes.

When two parties care deeply about an issue, tension is natural. But within that tension lies opportunity. These conversations can:

• Surface new ideas that would otherwise remain hidden.

• Challenge assumptions and lead to better decision-making.

• Build trust through honesty and transparency.

• Drive progress by confronting uncomfortable truths head-on.

In short, difficult conversations are where the real work happens. They are not distractions from progress—they are the engine of it.

What Makes Conversations Difficult?

Understanding why conversations become difficult is the first step to managing them effectively. Common reasons include:

• Emotional stakes: When people feel personally invested, emotions can run high. This is especially true when decisions affect livelihoods, services, or community wellbeing.

• Power dynamics: Conversations between officers and elected members, or between senior leaders and frontline staff, can be influenced by hierarchy and perceived authority.

• Uncertainty: When outcomes are unclear or decisions are unpopular, anxiety increases. People may fear change or feel they are losing control.

• Conflicting values: Differing political ideologies or professional perspectives can create friction, particularly when values are deeply held.

• Fear of consequences: People may worry about damaging relationships, reputations, or future opportunities.

Recognising these dynamics helps us prepare and respond more effectively. It also reminds us that difficulty often signals importance.

Reframing the Conversation

The first step in handling a difficult conversation is to reframe it. Instead of seeing it as a confrontation, view it as a collaboration. This shift in mindset can transform the tone and outcome of the discussion. Ask yourself:

• What is the shared goal here?

• What does success look like for both parties?

• How can we move from “me vs. you” to “us vs. the problem”?

This reframing encourages curiosity, empathy, and problem-solving—all essential ingredients for a productive dialogue. It also helps reduce defensiveness and opens the door to mutual understanding.

Strategy 1: Prepare with Purpose

Preparation is key. Before entering a difficult conversation, take time to:

• Clarify your objectives: What do you want to achieve? What are your non-negotiables? What are you willing to compromise on?

• Anticipate the other person’s perspective: What might they be feeling? What concerns or motivations might they have? What pressures are they under?

• Gather your data: Facts, figures, and evidence are your allies. They ground the conversation in reality and reduce the influence of emotion or speculation.

• Plan your opening: How you start sets the tone. Aim for calm, respectful, and constructive language.

Example: Instead of saying, “You’re blocking progress,” try, “I’d like to understand your concerns so we can find a way forward together.”

Strategy 2: Stay Grounded in Data

In local government, data is a powerful tool. Whether it’s financial modelling, service performance, or community feedback, data provides a shared reference point that can depersonalise the conversation. When emotions rise, return to the evidence:

• “Let’s look at what the data is telling us.”

• “Here’s what the consultation results show.”

• “This is the projected impact based on our modelling.”

Data doesn’t eliminate disagreement, but it shifts the focus from opinion to insight. It helps keep the conversation anchored in facts rather than feelings. And crucially, it provides a basis for accountability and transparency.

Strategy 3: Manage Emotions—Yours and Theirs

Emotions are not the enemy. They signal that people care. But unmanaged emotions can derail a conversation. Here’s how to stay composed:

• Breathe and pause: If you feel triggered, take a moment before responding. Silence can be powerful.

• Acknowledge feelings: “I can see this is frustrating for you” validates the other person’s experience without agreeing or disagreeing.

• Stay curious: Ask open questions to understand, not to challenge.

• Avoid blame: Focus on behaviours and outcomes, not personalities.

Remember, your tone and body language matter as much as your words. Calmness is contagious. If you remain composed, others are more likely to follow suit.

Strategy 4: Listen to Understand, Not to Win

Active listening is a superpower in difficult conversations. It builds rapport, reduces defensiveness, and often reveals common ground. Try this:

• Paraphrase: “So what I’m hearing is…”

• Ask clarifying questions: “Can you say more about what you mean by that?”

• Reflect back emotions: “It sounds like you’re feeling really concerned about this.”

Listening doesn’t mean agreeing. It means showing respect and creating space for dialogue. It also helps you spot misunderstandings early and correct them before they escalate.

Strategy 5: Focus on Progress, Not Perfection

In local government, we often deal with complex, “wicked” problems—issues with no perfect solution. The goal of a difficult conversation is not to win or to be right. It’s to move forward. Ask:

• “What’s one thing we can agree on today?”

• “What’s the next step we can take together?”

• “How can we keep this conversation going?”

Progress is incremental. Celebrate small wins and keep the door open for continued dialogue. Even partial agreement is a step in the right direction.

Strategy 6: Follow Up and Follow Through

A conversation doesn’t end when the meeting does. To build trust and momentum:

• Summarise agreements: “Here’s what we agreed and what happens next.”

• Document actions: Especially important in formal settings or politically sensitive discussions.

• Check in: Revisit the conversation later to see how things are progressing.

Consistency builds credibility. It shows that you value the conversation and are committed to outcomes. It also helps prevent misunderstandings and keeps everyone accountable.

Strategy 7: Know When to Escalate or Pause

Sometimes, despite your best efforts, a conversation may become unproductive or even hostile. In these cases:

• Take a break: Suggest pausing and reconvening later. Time can help people reflect and reset.

• Bring in a neutral third party: A facilitator or mediator can help reset the tone and guide the discussion.

• Escalate appropriately: If the issue is serious or persistent, follow organisational protocols.

Don’t see breakdowns as failure. They’re part of the process. What matters is how you respond and what you learn.

Real-World Example: Budget Cuts and Community Services

Imagine a scenario where a council must reduce funding for a popular community service due to budget constraints. Officers present the data: usage statistics, cost per user, and alternative provision options. Elected members, however, face strong opposition from residents and feel political pressure to maintain the service.

This is a classic difficult conversation. Emotions are high. Values clash. But by grounding the discussion in data, acknowledging community concerns, and exploring phased or alternative solutions, the conversation can shift from confrontation to collaboration. The outcome may not please everyone, but it can still reflect shared responsibility and thoughtful compromise.

Conclusion: Difficult Conversations Are a Leadership Skill

In local government, leadership isn’t just about strategy or policy—it’s about people. And people mean conversations. The ability to navigate difficult discussions with empathy, clarity, and courage is one of the most valuable skills you can develop.

As a leader, it is your job to have difficult conversations

These conversations are not distractions from the work—they are the work. They are where change happens, where relationships are strengthened, and where progress begins.

So next time you find yourself facing a difficult conversation, don’t shy away. Step in. Be prepared. Stay grounded. And remember: the most challenging conversations often lead to the most meaningful outcomes.